In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of. In my opinion, i believe that they are so different that they act as foil characters to each other. Bonding over nightmares, both the feeling of guilt, both found comfort in hans home etc. Their similar backgrounds make maxs initial gift of the standover man important, as max ultimately helps liesel realize the power of words to delight and to harm others. Jul 23, 2017 the narrative then quickly shifts to an attempt at tension, as liesel cant find the book on the shelf, and rudy warns her of footsteps coming from upstairs, but this is resolved in 2 paragraphs as she then sees the book lying on the mayors desk, grabs it, and jumps out the window again.
Rudy is blond and tall, liesel is darkhaired and small. Compare and contrast liesel and rudys motives for robbing the mayors house. Explain rudys reaction when he discovers that liesel is a book thief. Liesel back then blocked rudys goal so he threw a snowball in her face.
Examine how characters in the novel for example, liesel, max, ilsa hermann, hitler, rosa andor hans use words to destroy and to save. She is also aggressive and has a much brusquer manner in the way she acts. Hes the average kid who goes to school during the second world war who helps liesel in learning new things. The book thief the book thief is just a small story really, about, among other things. Dec 15, 2014 the book thief by mark zusak showcases a friendship of two people named rudy and liesel along with how their friendship had matured over the course of time and how it will continue to evolve.
But who other to tell the story then death himself, as he looks over the towns and cities of germany waiting for someone to take their last breath so he may take. The book thief compare and contrast essay the book thief by markus zusak follows the struggles of a young girl in nazi germany during world war ii. When liesel grew older and died, he was to present it to her as a gift. Write a 250word response based on our reading of the book thief pg.
In 1945, liesel works in the tailor shop owned by rudys father when max enters. The characters liesel meminger and rudy stiener are very similar in many ways. This was despite the a hansrequested visit from frau heinrich, who explained to the hubermanns that the foster care office had lost contact completely with paula meminger. Liesel is an orphan, rudy comes from a large, large family. Mar 15, 2010 compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenberg. I remember from the book how liesel and rudy found money on the ground but that wasnt enough money so they had to share it. Liesel is a very complex character in the book thief. Sep 14, 2010 liesels and papas conversation at the church against all hopelessness, liesel still checked the mailbox each afternoon, throughout march and well into april. Warner chappell, ascap, latinautor warner chappell. Rudy sees maxs name written on one of liesel s books and discovers the secret of max while he is still in the basement.
Therefore, the novel the book thief develops the relationship between liesel meminger and her neighbours more than the film the book thief thereby minimizing the theme. Book club the book thief, one of the most enduring stories of our time. Rosa, on the other hand, is usually very aggressive. Rudys father is conscripted after they turn down the request for. He states that the book thief died only yesterday, that she lived a long life in a place far away from munich and himmel street in a suburb of sydney. That night, liesel meminger truly became the book thief. Compare the distractions liesel finds in rudys friendship with those in the whistler. How is the relationship between hans and liesel and rosa and. Both the texts once and the book thief are set during the same world war two, but they are set in different locations. After hans is seen giving some bread to a jew, they are both whipped by a nazi officer. Jan 25, 2015 liesel and rudy sad song the book thief duration. Rudy and liesel rudy and liesel problems rudy steiner well. His love grows and grows right up to the bitter end.
In the book thief how is the relationship between liesel and. Now, i must preface this by saying i always find the book better than the movie, but i dont think ive ever been so let down by a book tofilm adaptation in my life. For example, rosa hubermann is described as being a woman who looked like a small wardrobe with a coat thrown over it. His work is translated into more than forty languages, and has spent more than a decade on the new york times bestseller list, establishing zusak as one of the most successful authors to come out of australia. The book thief is a story narrated by a compassionate death who tells us about liesel, a girl growing up in germany during world war ii. Rudy and liesel rudy and lieselproblems rudy steiner well. Compare liesel and rudy in a venn diagram the book thief. In this fanfic rudy and liesel get the happy ending that they deserv. Aug 12, 2015 in the novel, death picked up liesel s book because he felt it was important.
How does zusak use the literary device of foreshadowing to pull the reader into the story. Rudy steiner character analysis in the book thief litcharts. Markus zusaks novel, the book thief, is full of literary techniques that lend. Dec 11, 2015 the story of book thief is about liesel meminger and is told by the death, who is haunted by humans. The book thief compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenberg. The novel the book thief develops the relationship between hans hubermann and liesel meminger more than the film the book thief therefore minimizing the theme. The book thief markus zusak, 2006 random house childrens 576 pp. Jul 15, 20 rudy is motivated throughout the novel by his love for liesel. By the end of the novel, liesel has come to love rudy as well. In addition to liesel, the book thief of the title, characters who particularly stand out are rudy steiner, a close friend who is obsessed with the. He starts off in the novel as a tenyearold boy with. The book thief why is rudy and liesels friendship a. However, in the movie, liesel actually goes as far as to tell rudy about hiding max. The book thief by mark zusak showcases a friendship of two people named rudy and liesel along with how their friendship had matured over the course of time and how it will continue to evolve.
The first letter is from rudy s heart and it is the true form of how rudy is and how he feels about liesel. Its january 1939, and ten year old liesel is traveling by train with her mother and her little brother werner. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Markus zusak is the international bestselling author of six novels, including the book thief and most recently, bridge of clay. The book thief is narrated by death yup, you heard that right who tells us the story of liesel meminger.
One way they are similar is because they both enjoy some of the same activities, like soccer and stealing. In the book thief how is the relationship between liesel. Liesel usually finds hans, her foster father, to be quiet and uncomplicated. Having liesel witness rudys death, in the film, caused her to be overwhelmed and to pass out. Whats the difference between the book thief the book and the book thief the movie. The book thief by markus zusak book club discussion. In the care of the hubermans, liesel befriends rudy steiner and together they steal books from nazi book burning piles, from the mayors library. When liesel moved to 33 himmelstreet rudy became her next door neighbour.
She steals books, learns to read, and finds comfort in words. Compare and contrast the differences and similarities between the setting in each text. It was the first time liesel had been branded with her title, and she couldnt hide the fact that she liked it very much. My book club discussed this book last night and we all gave it 5 stars. Leo draveling liesel meminger is a 9 year old girl experiencing the hardships of nazi germany in 1939, while hitler is in power.
In the book thief, words have the power to both destroy and save lives. How does stealing books from the mayors house lead to a friendship. Compare and contrast liesel and rudy s motives for robbing the mayors house. Rudy finds out about max after he has left the basement. Were talking both friendly love and romantic love, in rudys case. Apr 20, 2011 while reading the beginning chapters of the book thief, i noticed that there were some very definite differences between liesels foster parents rosa and hans hubermann.
Having lost her father because of his communist sympathies, and soon thereafter her brother and mother, she understands the pain of loss, and these experiences inform her actions and attitudes towards the other characters. With one eye open, one still in a dream, the book thiefalso known as liesel memingercould see without question that her. Liesel has been separated from her parents kommunists for ever. Adults will probably like it this one did, but its a great youngadult novel. Max and liesel both have nightmares about their past and suffer from survivors guilt. Sep 23, 2010 write a 250word response based on our reading of the book thief pg. The book thief was published for adults in zusaks native australia, and i strongly suspect it was written for adults. Liesel meminger is the hardworking, bookthieving, kindhearted star of the novel. Get an answer for in the book thief how is the relationship between liesel and rudy like family, lovers, strangers, and enemies. The story, narrated by death himself, follows a young girl as she arrives in a small town in germany to live with her new foster parents as ww2 looms. Write notes about two possible topics for your essay from those suggested below power of language one option. Write notes about two possible topics for your essay from those suggested below. There was a distinct waddle to her walk almost cute if it wasnt for her face, which was like creasedup cardboard and annoyed, as if she was merely tolerating the situation page 27. The film showed liesel s house, when she was older, and on a desk was the book thief.
The book thief why is rudy and liesels friendship a good. The book thief compare liesel and rudy in a venn diagram. The big discussion topic was whether or not liesel and max got married in the end. In the movie max dreams of becoming a boxer and fighting hitler. One way they are similar is because they both enjoy some of. You must respond to this post as well as a fellow group members post. Although in this story the friendship is more of rudy in love with liesel, but liesel was also filled with a brotherly love. Compare and contrast the characters liesel meminger and rudy stiener are very similar in many ways. Feb 26, 2015 after finishing the book with tears in my eyes, i decided to rent the book thief movie from my local library to compare the two mediums. In the book thief how is the relationship between liesel and rudy. He enjoys reading with liesel and will usually do simple activities with her that she finds fun. As were both aware, shed stolen books previously, but in late october 1941, it became official. One of them, the infamous rudy, would soon become liesels best friend, and later, her partner and. Review of the book thief essays 1174 words bartleby.
Were talking both friendly love and romantic love, in rudy s case. What does rudy possess that leave him constantly at odds with the nazi society in which he lives. I read the book thief and am wondering what are some good compare and contrast points when looking at max and liesel. By only showing this one does not fully see how much words can impact a community. How is the relationship between hans and liesel and rosa. I decided to rent the book thief movie from my local library to compare the two mediums. Death says that he would like to tell the book thief about beauty and brutality. Rudy, the boy who refuses to fear the opposite sex 8. Licensed to youtube by wmg on behalf of east west records uk ltd. Get an answer for in the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max. Liesel is known to have complicated relationships with her foster parents. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel. The protagonist of the book, liesel is also its moral center.
In the novel, death picked up liesels book because he felt it was important. Liesel did not know how to read until this book and it was a milestone for her to finish her book in what ways is rudy s first letter to liesel more appropriate than the second, approved version. He forms a real connection with his pal, liesel, and shows his commitment to her throughout the novel. Compare and contrast liesels and rudys motive s for robbing the mayors house. Liesel gets angry and throws a book at ilsa when she is told she wont be delivering the laundry anymore. Liesels and papas conversation at the church against all hopelessness, liesel still checked the mailbox each afternoon, throughout march and well into april.
Rudy and liesel are like brother and sister in the fact that they spend a lot of time together. An american girl chrissa stands strong movie american duration. Death, liesel meminger, hans hubermann, rosa hubermann, max vandenburg, rudy steiner, alex steiner. Rudy sees maxs name written on one of liesels books and discovers the secret of max while he is still in the basement. Max gives liesel a story called, the standover man for her birthday. Once takes place during world war two, just like the book thief.
Compare and contrast arthur berg and victor chemmel. Having liesel witness rudy s death, in the film, caused her to be overwhelmed and to pass out. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 1. Compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenburg. The theme, the power of words, is minimized in the film as only the scenes in which liesel and frau hermann and liesel and rudy develop relationships. Until, that is, the day he rescues the whistler from the amper river. With death, himself, as the narrator, you know it is going to be an amazing journey. When she first comes to live with her foster family, the. Comparative essay the book thief 1722 words bartleby. There are many conflicts in the book that lead back to. Liesel not only cares about specific people in her life such as hans, rudy, and max, she cares about justice in general, and feels frustrated and angry at the. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 2.
A continuation of the conversation liesel and rudy had when liesel showed him the word shacker and liesel realized her love for rudy. There are many conflicts in the book that lead back to liesel. Her soul, like her papas, sat up when death came for her, and as she went she thought of her three children, her grandchildren, her husband, and the many loved ones from her past, especially. The film showed liesels house, when she was older, and on a desk was the book thief. Both are political refugees evading nazi persecution. The book thief book vs film with a book as beloved as markus zusaks the book thief, an adaptation was always going to be a challenge. Do not read this if you havent read the book because there are things in it that you wont understand unless youve read it. Examine how characters in the novel for example, liesel, max, ilsa hermann, hitler, rosa and. Ever since it was first published in 2005, the book became wildly popular and had won many awards. The story of book thief is about liesel meminger and is told by the death, who is haunted by humans. Liesel she wants a book because she was earning it, she needs the book to survive reading to max, power of words rudy after being defeated multiple times at hitler youth, he needs to win, rudy wants food and needs it to survive. Compare and contrast for the book, night, and the book thief as a language arts assignment.394 459 1563 318 863 61 188 1498 1452 687 73 878 154 1429 284 173 1538 1302 934 981 600 1512 759 616 437 877 393 390 261 1256 1161 1040 1158 12 897 1017 207 975 1150 170 82 982 661 932 1097